What is the Best Video Editing Software?

To start with, we’re going to compare Apple Final Cut Pro and Sony Vegas Pro. I know these products are only indirect competitors due to their different platforms, but these are the only programs I have extensively used. If you would like more specific advise, you’ll have to ask someone else.

Final Cut Pro (FCP) is very much an industry standard and is often used along side with high-end systems from Avid, Media100, or Leitch in production facilities. Many theatrical movies and television shows have been edited in FCP which Apple loves to tout at industry conventions. FCP is also a standard in many education institutes so most new editors entering the video industry are trained on it.

That being said, most timeline-based editors such as Vegas and FCP function in a very similar manner. Although the specific names of functions and keyboard shortcuts may change, the same concepts apply and are fairly easy to apply to different editing software. Most new editors (usually with a Premiere or FCP background) can be trained on Vegas very quickly.

Personally I use Vegas because I have a PC and therefore cannot use FCP on it. I considered Adobe Premiere as well several years ago before making the purchase, but chose Vegas for several reasons:

  1. Vegas supports putting nearly any file on the timeline without additional conversions. Premiere requires many “non-standard” files (such as DivX) to be converted to a supported format before they can be edited.
  2. Vegas supports 3D tracks allowing for fairly complex compositions right in the timeline without need for addition FX software.
  3. Vegas supported real-time native HDV playback from the timeline (which Premiere didn’t at the time).
  4. Vegas bundles DVD Architect which (at the time) was significantly less expensive than a Premiere/Encore bundle.

I know I’ve dived into a bit of a Premiere comparison above, but it is another major player. On the PC side, Premiere has some advantages over Vegas as well. Premiere’s built-in titler is far superior to Vegas, and DVD Authoring with Adobe Encore is well integrated with Photoshop making complex DVD Menus way easier to build then using Sony’s DVD Architect.

On the Mac side, FCP has a number of advantages over Vegas including a fantastic titler (LiveType), superior DVD Authoring (with DVD Studio Pro), and supports a variety of hardware that Vegas does not.

If you’re planning on editing for primarily your own purposes, I would suggest you go ahead and learn Vegas. It’s a very powerful piece of software and quite inexpensive compared to other players in the marketplace. If you’re planning on getting a Mac in the future anyways OR want software experience that is more marketable, buy FCP with it and get started with that instead.

enjoyed this post? share with others:

twitter stumble upon digg

This entry was posted on Wednesday, January 7th, 2009 at 7:27 pm and is filed under Opinion, Software. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.

Comments are closed.